SION - The civil bill for the Crans-Montana fire is now a question about who would pay it. Lawyer Sébastien Fanti, who represents victims, confirmed on Sunday to Keystone-SDA that he has asked the Valais Council of State for two things: an official inquiry into the municipality's finances, and a partial compulsory administration limited to the financial and legal consequences of the fire. He was confirming a report in Le Matin Dimanche and the SonntagsZeitung.

CHF 5 million a year against a much larger claim

Fanti said his office worked from the published accounts, and that the result was clear: the municipality does not have the means to meet a possible liability. The complaint, which AFP reported was filed on 19 October, says the total cost for the town could run to several hundred million francs. The CHF 5 million a year written into the municipal budget would not cover that. He says the canton has to move quickly, because the 2027 budget is due to be adopted on 20 December.

The request for administration is narrow. It would cover the executive's handling of the financial and legal aftermath, not the whole municipality. Fanti's argument is that waiting for an ordinary budget debate leaves victims facing a town that cannot pay.

The canton says oversight is not a guarantee

The cantonal information service told Keystone-SDA that the complaint is being examined. Municipalities, it said, are responsible for their own finances. A town that shows a deficit has to draw up a financial plan and recovery measures. If the balance cannot be restored over the long term, the canton can appoint a commissioner to write that plan and propose the measures. The law allows supervision that can, in some cases, go as far as compulsory administration.

Those powers are not a promise that Valais will stand behind the debt. The canton said an intervention of that kind is not a cantonal guarantee. If Crans-Montana one day cannot meet its obligations, the government would look at help such as a guarantee or a loan. It has not offered either.

The criminal case is still open

The money question sits beside a criminal investigation that has not closed. Mayor Nicolas Féraud remains in office and is one of 17 people under investigation by the Valais prosecutor for negligent homicide, negligent bodily injury and negligent arson. The others include current and former municipal officials and staff, and Jacques and Jessica Moretti, the French owners and managers of the bar Le Constellation. The fire on New Year's night killed 41 people and injured 115. Investigators have said fountain candles set light to sound-proofing foam on the basement ceiling. AFP reported that Jacques Moretti was due to be questioned again on Monday.

Ten months on, the resort is heading into another winter season with the criminal file open and the civil exposure unquantified. What Fanti has put in front of the Council of State is a deadline: the 2027 budget, and a claim that the line already in the accounts is not big enough for the liability the town may face.