BERN - The board of RUAG MRO Holding commissioned the Zurich firm Niederer Kraft Frey on 31 August 2023, after irregularities in business with Leopard 1 tanks. The report, released on Friday, looks at the years since 2002. It is not limited to tanks. It records what the company describes as a series of matters that may be criminal. Several criminal complaints have been filed, for disloyal management, document forgery, breach of manufacturing or trade secrets, and further offences. Those cases have been added to more than once, the company said. Proceedings are open in Switzerland and in Germany against former employees. The people concerned are presumed innocent. A civil claim by Ruag is already before a Swiss court.

Where the 51 million euros comes from

Ruag MRO wants 51 million euros in damages from ten people, plus interest. The report puts 46.9 million euros on the resale of Dutch tank parts below market value. A further 4 million euros is tied to the sale of 22 tank gearboxes to firms in the circle of an employee. Apart from a first-instance conviction in Germany of a former Ruag employee for granting an undue advantage, the criminal cases are still open. That German judgment is not final: the prosecutor has appealed.

The report says actions for liability against former company organs, including the board, are not planned on the evidence now in hand. It does not rule them out if the criminal and civil cases produce more. That is the line Saturday's news led with, and it is a narrower line than a finding of board liability. The board has said it accepts, without reservation, the compliance breaches and the weak controls the review found, and that measures from the investigation are being put in place.

Pfister orders a federal reading of the file

Martin Pfister, head of the Federal Department of Defence, said the failings damage public trust in a firm that matters to Switzerland's ability to defend itself. He welcomed the fact that the board had the past examined. He has still ordered his own follow-up. A working group in the defence department will read the report in detail, clarify the responsibility of Ruag's organs and of the owner, and judge whether the steps Ruag has taken are enough. It will also look at how Ruag works with its main customer, the army. Pfister wants the results in front of the Federal Council in two to three months. The Federal Council and the parliamentary control and finance delegations have been informed.

At the department's request, the Council of States security committee will not debate a full revision of the law on federal arms companies before the start of 2027 at the earliest. The delay is meant to leave room to change the draft if the inquiry changes the case for how Ruag should be organised.

Spare parts blocked, tanks kept running

The review flags a separate risk: parts made from drawings that were passed on, and built by manufacturers who were not approved, may have reached Ruag stores and workshops, or Leopard 2 tanks of the Swiss army. The defence department has had spare parts blocked where they might come from an unapproved maker. It says it and Ruag have taken steps so the Leopard 2 fleet stays operational. The report also says Ruag used material from consignment stocks for business with third parties. The Federal Audit Office had already noted weaknesses there in a report at the start of 2025. The department has been tracing responsibility inside the administration and says that work is well advanced. It will speak when the results are in.

Two clocks are now running. One is the courts, in Switzerland and in Germany, on the people already named in criminal and civil files. The other is Bern's, on whether the board, past and present, and the federal owner did the supervision the law expects. Friday's report answers the first question only in part. It leaves the second one open on purpose.