BERN - Protection status S was the fast shelter Switzerland opened after Russia's full-scale invasion. It is not a full asylum grant. It lets people stay, work, and receive support while the federal government judges that return is not reasonable. For applicants from seven regions in the west of Ukraine, Bern now says return is reasonable.
Seven western regions still classed as safe
The State Secretariat for Migration has kept that map even after Russian attacks that killed civilians in the west. The secretariat's line, as the Sunday paper reports it, is that a single attack does not automatically make a return unreasonable. The seven regions stay on the safe list. People refused status S in the period above were told to go back.
The 286 refusals are a slice of a much larger protection population. Cantons still house people who received status S earlier, and some of those residents are moving onto ordinary permits. Graubünden wants Ukrainians who gain a B permit in 2027 to stay 20 percent below the local social-assistance rate, a cut that would cover about 960 people.
The political split in Bern
Social Democrat National Councillor Fabian Molina has attacked the refusals and wants protection status S restored for all Ukrainians. The Swiss People's Party and the FDP defend the split between regions judged safe and regions judged unsafe. SVP National Councillor Pascal Schmid points to the distance between western Ukraine and the front. He also cites the cost of status S and what he describes as abuse of it.
The argument is no longer only about new arrivals. It is about who Switzerland will still protect three years into the war, and who it will send back. A separate track with Italy is moving the other way: Rome has told Bern in writing that Dublin asylum transfers can resume. Status S and Dublin returns are different legal doors. Both now sit on the same Sunday political agenda, next to the internal review of the Lex On Swissness change.
