ZURICH - The motion came from the Alternative List. Tanja Maag told the chamber that people still have reasons to pay with cash: no bank account, a wish to stay anonymous, or a refusal to feed what she called surveillance capitalism. She asked whether a child should need a card to buy something small. The left and the SVP voted together. The GLP, the FDP and the Centre voted no. City councillor Andreas Hauri, a Green Liberal standing in for mayor Raphael Golta, had asked parliament to reject the motion. He said a duty on every organisation that receives even one franc from the city would be too strict, and that public pressure had already worked.
The Kunsthaus and the station Christmas market
Two recent cases set the debate. The Kunsthaus ran without cash for four months and has taken notes and coins again since January. Last year's Polarzauber market at the main station announced a cashless fair and reversed that plan within days after the complaints. Christmas markets in the city open in less than four weeks. An earlier SVP postulate, limited to city operations, is still with the executive. The Alternative List said that text did not go far enough and asked for the municipal code itself to change.
Public ground was the compromise
The original motion also covered businesses that trade on public land, which would have caught market stalls. Sofia Karakostas of the Social Democrats moved to drop that part, arguing it collided with economic freedom. The Alternative List accepted the cut, and the 73-to-44 majority followed. Samuel Balsiger of the SVP welcomed the left's language of independence from card companies. Yves Henz of the Greens pictured a grandfather at a stall with a 20-franc note and nothing to buy. FDP speaker Emanuel Tschannen said private firms should decide their own tills.
Federal currency law says cash must in principle be accepted, and it also allows that duty to be limited by contract. The city council had said a general rule for every user of public land went beyond what the city should impose on small businesses. Parliament has now ordered a draft anyway, for city bodies and for subsidised ones. Until that draft is written and passed, a venue can still choose its tills. The vote binds the executive to prepare the text. It does not yet bind the Kunsthaus box office.
