BERN - The committee voted on Monday. RTS reported the recommendation on Tuesday morning. It asks the full National Council to follow the Council of States, which voted 23 to 17 on 30 September to submit the agreements to a mandatory referendum, and therefore to the double majority of people and cantons. The National Council debates the question in the winter session in December.
A popular yes would still need twelve cantons
If the chamber follows the committee, a narrow popular yes would not ratify the package, which its supporters call Bilaterals III. The treaties would also need the votes of at least twelve cantons. That is a high bar. Relations with the European Union divide many of the smaller cantons.
The vote sits on top of an earlier constraint. Because the treaties are not expected through parliament this winter in finished form, a nationwide ballot in 2027 is already out of reach. The earliest referendum is 2028. A double majority would shape that later vote. It would not bring the date forward.
A referendum form the constitution does not already set
To impose the double majority, parliament is moving toward a referendum of a special form that the constitution does not already provide. Supporters say the reach of the new agreements justifies it, in particular their effect on how Swiss institutions work.
Opponents of that reading say the aim is to stop the treaties. National Council member Delphine Klopfenstein Broggini, a Green from Geneva, called it "a manoeuvre by the SVP to block these bilaterals, to close itself off from the rest of Europe and to seal the borders." She said it is working because the FDP and part of the Centre are ready to follow that path.
The immigration levy stays undecided
The same committee declined to take a position on the immigration levy introduced by the Council of States. It said too many questions about the fee remain open. Under the current design, a charge of CHF 4,000 on EU nationals would apply only if Bern switches on a safeguard clause in the next EU package. The National Council still has to vote on that fee, most likely in December, separately from the question of who must approve the treaties.
