BERN - Before the winter session, in which the National Council takes up the new treaty package with the European Union for the first time, Pfister has put a new proposal before the Political Institutions Committee. Voters would first decide, in a vote of their own, whether the later treaty ballot needs a cantonal majority as well as a popular majority. He told SRF he expects the parliamentary decision on that hurdle to be close, and that it is better to let the public set the rules.
Why he calls it a fallback
Pfister, a former president of the Centre, wants the package to need the cantons. He expects the National Council, unlike the Council of States, to refuse that. If the houses disagree, a conciliation conference of 13 members from each foreign affairs committee would decide. Looking at those committees, he told SRF, he believes the demand for a cantonal majority would lose. The proposal is meant for colleagues who share his aim but think parliament will not deliver it. His line, as reported by SRF, is that they must choose the sparrow in the hand or the pigeon on the roof.
A National Council committee has already backed a double majority, by 14 votes to 11. The foreign affairs committee of the same house has taken the other view, that a popular majority is enough. That split is why a prior vote on the rules is now on the table.
The Compass Initiative and the calendar
Pfister's text is a counter-proposal to the Compass Initiative. The Compass Europe alliance wants important international treaties that contain legislative rules to go automatically to a mandatory referendum of the people and the cantons. Its text would also apply to the EU package if the treaties had already been voted on when the initiative passed. Pfister's counter-proposal would cover only this package. In the preliminary vote he wants, a simple majority of voters would be enough to drop the cantonal hurdle.
The alliance has little time for the idea. It still wants the package put to the cantons, but it told SRF that parliament itself must take this decision. It is also pushing for a ballot in June 2027. That date looks out of reach. Council of States President Stefan Engler told SRF last weekend that the upper house has no sitting this winter to settle differences with the National Council, so a 2027 vote is excluded. The earliest vote on the Bilateral III treaties is 2028. The same calendar would apply to a ballot on the cantonal majority, if Pfister's proposal wins a majority in parliament.
